Rights · Improper charges
I'm being charged for something I didn't authorize: how to stop it and who to complain to
Insurance that renewed itself, a debit that keeps going, a service you canceled that still appears on your statement. The usual response is "report it to the Central Bank," and that's only half true: the Central Bank of Uruguay (BCU) does supervise and penalize, but He cannot order them to give you your money back.Here is the complete route, in the order in which it is best to do it.
First, let it stop
Before the substantive claim. Ordered from most to least legally certain — terminating the contract and cutting off the means of payment are two different things, and both must be done.
It's the only thing that terminates the contract; everything else terminates the payment instrument. The general rule is Article 13 of Law 19.678: the policyholder can terminate at any time, without stating a reason, by giving one month's written notice, and the insurer is only entitled to the premium for the risk incurred up to that point. Beware of the shortcut: that same article EXCEPT for personal insurance, which is governed by Article 104 and can only be terminated after the first year, unless otherwise agreed. Which of the two applies depends on how YOUR policy is classified, and a 45-day coverage doesn't even have a first year: don't assume it, check it on the policy paperwork.
This is the strongest argument when you're being charged for insurance tied to something that's already over, and hardly anyone uses it. Law 19.678, Article 14: "The insurance contract shall be null and void if, at the time of its execution, the risk did not exist or the loss had already occurred. If the risk disappears after coverage has begun, the contract is terminated from the moment this circumstance comes to the insurer's attention by any means, and the insurer may only collect the premium for the period elapsed up to that moment." Travel insurance covers a trip: once the trip is over, the risk has disappeared. Notify the insurer in writing—the law says "by any means," so your own notification triggers the termination.
Not to the company: to the entity that debits your account. "The payer may revoke the payment order granted at any time, up to the end of the business day prior to the agreed date for the automatic debit" (Law 19.210, art. 70). And if you dispute the authorization, the bank has 5 business days to prove that the transaction was authorized; after that period, the dispute is considered confirmed and the refund will be processed in no more than 1 business day, including financial costs (arts. 72 and 73).
The contract must stipulate that the card will become invalid before its expiration date at the cardholder's request, and the issuer must cancel it from the system (Law 19.731, Article 14, Section C). Furthermore, they must refund the proportional amount of the annual fee charged in advance but not used. It's inconvenient, but it's what is explicitly supported by law.
There is no legal time limit in days for reporting unauthorized transactions: the law states "immediately upon detection" (Law 19.731, art. 17, lit. B). However, the date of your notification is the most valuable piece of evidence, because the Compilation makes you responsible for unauthorized transactions up to the moment of notification (RNRCSF, art. 367). A dated email is worth more than three phone calls.
Who can do what
The third column is the deciding one. Putting months of expectation in the wrong window is the costly mistake in this matter.
| Where | Supervise | Sanctions | Order the return | What does it really achieve? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The company The bank and the insurance company, each on their own | — | — | No | It's the only window that can give you a refund without a fight: if it acknowledges the error, the rule gives it 30 days to reimburse, at your choice in cash or to your account, and with interest if the improper charge is attributable to the institution. Response within 15 calendar days, extendable once for another 15 days with written notice |
| BCU Central Bank of Uruguay — Superintendency of Financial Services | Yeah | Yeah | No | The institution's conduct will be reviewed and, if necessary, sanctioned. It will end in a written resolution. The fine is collected by the State, not you. It is submitted only after 15 calendar days have passed since the claim was filed with the company |
| Consumer Protection Consumer Protection Area — Ministry of Economy and Finance | — | Yeah | No | A conciliation hearing where the company can agree to reimburse you. The agency itself cites "canceling a contract" and "canceling a financial debt" as examples of what can be resolved through this process. No published legal deadline |
| Magistrate's court Consumption process under Law 18.507, up to 100 UR | — | — | Yeah | The refund order. It's the only one on the list that can issue it. No lawyer required, a 1% stamp duty on the amount claimed, and no prior conciliation. The action EXPIRES one year after the event |
If your problem is not with a bank or an insurance company, the organization changes. See the complete route by category .
The documents that need to be requested
In the order they are served. The last one is the one that almost everyone skips.
- The complete policy, with the specific conditions (Law 19.678 art. 24).
- The document where it is stated that you agreed to the automatic renewal (Law 19.678 art. 6).
- If it was sold to you together with the card: written consent in a SEPARATE document, or the recording if it was by telephone (RNRCSF art. 384.1).
- Account statements with each charge marked, one by one.
- Proof of your claim, including date, time, and identification number. Without that, the rest of the process cannot begin.
What does the rule say, verbatim?
Cite them with the item number in your complaint. Change the tone of your response.
Automatic renewal must be agreed upon.
"The parties may agree to the automatic renewal or extension of the insurance... unless they intend to modify the current conditions, in which case the express consent of the policyholder must be obtained. If the modifications are not accepted, the contract will be terminated upon its scheduled expiration."
Law 19.678, art. 6
The correct question isn't "Can they renew?" but rather "Is renewal stipulated in MY specific terms and conditions?" I requested written documentation of this agreement. If it doesn't exist, the charge for the next period has no contractual basis.
How to cut short a renewal that was already agreed upon
"Either party may terminate this agreement by giving written notice to the other party thirty calendar days in advance of the conclusion of the current insurance period."
Law 19.678, art. 6
If the renewal was agreed upon, it's not that you can't leave: it's that you have to give written notice 30 calendar days before the end of the current period.
If the risk disappeared, the contract is automatically terminated
"The insurance contract will be void if, at the time of its conclusion, the risk did not exist or the loss had already occurred. If the risk disappears after coverage has begun, the contract is terminated from the moment this circumstance comes to the insurer's knowledge by any means, and the insurer may only receive the premium for the period elapsed up to that moment."
Law 19.678, art. 14
The strongest and least used argument when the insurance was tied to something that has already ended—a trip, a property you sold, a loan you paid off. You don't dispute the renewal: you say the risk no longer exists. And since the rule states "by any means," your own written notice makes the renewal effective from that date.
What they'll tell you is: "You paid, so you accepted."
"Payment of the prize or the first installment will imply acceptance of its amount."
Law 19.678, art. 6, paragraph 4
Anticipate this, because it's the standard defense. The response is based on what the article says and what it doesn't say: it accepts the AMOUNT, not the existence of a renewal that was never agreed upon. And in a consumer relationship, this directly contradicts Article 31, section H of Law 17.250, which deems abusive any clause that interprets your silence as acceptance. Honesty above all: we haven't found any published Uruguayan ruling that resolves this tension, so this is an argument, not a certainty.
Your silence is not acceptance.
"that the consumer's silence will be considered as acceptance of any modification, restriction or extension of what was agreed"
Law 17.250, art. 31 lit. H — is an ABUSIVE clause
Against the "you didn't say anything, so it was renewed" approach. Law 19.731 reiterates this for credit cards in its article 13 and concludes: "The inclusion of abusive clauses in the contract between the issuer and the user will not bind the latter and will be null and void."
The 60 days to undo an automatic renewal
"The consumer may, within sixty calendar days from the date of automatic renewal, terminate or cancel the contract... the provider having a maximum of fifteen calendar days to process the cancellation."
Law 17.250, art. 31 lit. I (wording of art. 185 of Law 20.212, in force 1/1/2024)
It's the shortcut, and let's be honest: if the renewal was more than two months ago, that option is already closed. The other two options remain, and they're better—unsolicited charges and unsolicited service.
You don't pay for a service you didn't request.
"They do not entail any obligation to pay or return them, thus being equivalent to free samples"
Law 17.250, art. 22 lit. D (services provided without prior request)
This is the fundamental argument and the one that changes the game: you're not arguing about the price, you're arguing that there's no obligation to pay it.
Insurance that was not agreed upon cannot be claimed.
"Institutions may not charge interest, fees, expenses, commissions, rates, fines, insurance or other amounts that have not been previously and expressly agreed upon."
RNRCSF, art. 359 (and art. 379 for all charges on the statement of account)
This is the regulation that makes your claim something the Central Bank of Uruguay (BCU) actually oversees. Cite it with the number: it requires the institution to show where you agreed to it.
If you bought it along with the card, the consent form is on a separate sheet of paper.
"obtain written consent in a separate document from the credit card contract"
RNRCSF, art. 384.1
I requested that separate document. If the sale was made by telephone, the regulation requires a recording with the phrase "I agree to purchase the product [NAME] for the price of [PRICE]", and anyone who does not have that record must, at the customer's request, consider the contract terminated and refund the amount paid.
The issuer has to provide proof, and not only in cases of fraud.
"If this cannot be proven, the issuer will be liable for the transaction claimed... for the purposes of complying with this obligation, the conditions of contracts that the issuer may have signed with third parties will not be applicable."
RNRCSF, art. 364 lit. h (and Law 19.731 art. 15 lit. F)
In the event of a claim regarding a transaction, the issuer must demonstrate that it was carried out according to the agreed-upon procedures and properly authenticated. And the last sentence is the one that matters: "the insurance company sent it to me" is not a defense.
They have to give you the policy.
"within thirty calendar days of the contract being entered into or whenever it is modified"
Law 19.678, art. 24
In Spanish, legibly, and via a method that allows proof of receipt. If they never gave it to you, that's part of the claim—and without a policy, it's difficult for them to maintain that the renewal was agreed upon.
The traps
That causes you to lose money, time, or the entire right.
Stop paying the fee while you claim
No regulation suspends the enforceability of the charge while the claim is being processed. Once default is established, interest can legally reach the average rates of the Central Bank of Uruguay (BCU) plus 80% on transactions below 2:000.000 UI (Law 18.212, Art. 11). Afterward, the issuer reports the arrears to the BCU's Risk Center, and the debt may end up in the Clearing de Informes (Credit Information Clearing), a private database where unpaid debts are listed for five years (Law 18.331, Art. 22). Getting out of the Clearing de Informes is more expensive than the installment you're disputing: pay under protest and fight for a refund.
"I pay everything except the charge I'm disputing."
It doesn't protect you. The allocation of partial payments is determined by the contract (RNRCSF art. 378 lit. g), so the difference can remain as an unpaid balance and still generate late payment charges.
Believing that the Central Bank of Uruguay (BCU) will give you your money back
This is the central trap, and the agency itself corrects it: it cannot order the return of any amount, nor award damages, nor resolve a contractual dispute between parties. All of that falls under the exclusive jurisdiction of the courts. Filing a complaint is still useful—it's recorded and reflects on the conduct of the supervised institution—but if you're seeking the money back, there's another way.
Going to the BCU without having previously filed a complaint with the institution
They reject your application: the procedure requires attaching a copy of the complaint filed with the institution and a copy of the response, if there was one. This requirement is from the published procedure, not the regulation—but it's just as relevant when it comes to actually getting your application accepted.
Confusing a claim with a complaint to Consumer Protection
They're not the same process. A complaint is a mediation procedure, and it's what can result in the company refunding your money. A formal complaint seeks a penalty, and the agency itself clarifies that it's not for obtaining compensation. To get your money back: file a complaint.
Accepting a "your deadline has passed" as if it were the law
The time limits for disputing charges published by issuers are derived from their contract terms, not from a regulation: no Uruguayan law sets a specific number. And in a recurring charge, each installment is a new charge, so the clock starts ticking for each debit, not from the first one.
Discuss it as if it were fraud
It isn't, and framing it that way puts you in a position where the law works against you (you are responsible for unauthorized transactions until you notify us, RNRCSF art. 367). Classify it as an uncontracted charge (arts. 359, 361 and 379) and as an unsolicited service (Law 17.250 art. 22 lit. D).
Should you file a claim only against the bank, or only against the insurance company?
These are two offices with the same deadline but different rules: the bank according to Article 327 of the Regulation and Control Compilation, the insurance company according to Article 86.6 of the Insurance Law. Submit your application to both and request a confirmation number at both.
Let the year pass by
The quick and inexpensive route—the consumer case in the Justice of the Peace Court, up to 100 UR, without mandatory legal representation—expires one year after the incident. After that, there is the ordinary trial, which is a different matter in terms of both time and cost.
Confusing the financing term with the coverage term
Just because a policy is paid in 12 installments doesn't make it annual, and just because it covers 45 days doesn't make it monthly. There are annual travel assistance policies with a limit of 45 consecutive days per trip, financed in 12 installments that coincide with the coverage year. Before arguing, check the policy: if it says "annual multi-trip," the claim isn't "I was overcharged" but rather "they renewed the next period without my consent," which is a different claim and governed by different regulations.
What is not published
We look for it and it doesn't exist. We say it instead of estimating it: in this matter, a made-up figure leads you to argue with a baseless argument.
- How long does Consumer Protection take? The agency mentions an expected processing time, not a legal deadline: there is no regulation that establishes it.
- If a recurring credit card charge falls under the automatic debit regime of Law 19.210—the 5 business days to provide proof and 1 day to issue a refund—Article 68 already names the associated cards, but the definition still refers to an account or electronic money instrument and requires a framework agreement. It can be invoked; it cannot be promised.
- If the bank is jointly liable with the insurer for insurance sold at its branch, there is no bancassurance regulation that establishes this. However, it is clear that the bank is a service provider for the purposes of Law 17.250 and has its own duty to address your claim.
- Can the issuer refuse to issue a refund by invoking their contractual deadline when the rule mandating reimbursement does not establish a time limit for the customer? This is the central issue in this type of case, and no primary source resolves it.
- Whether Article 6, paragraph 4 of Law 19.678—"payment of the bonus or the first installment implies acceptance of its amount"—is sufficient to validate a renewal that was never agreed upon, or whether it only accepts the amount, conflicts with Article 31, section H of Law 17.250, and we have found no published Uruguayan ruling that resolves this issue.
- Which of the two cancellation policies applies to travel assistance: Article 13 of Law 19.678 (cancellation at any time with one month's notice) or Article 104 (cancellation only after the first year), which applies to personal insurance? A 45-day policy doesn't have a first year, so the text doesn't resolve the issue. It depends on the policy's classification.
- Whether insurance brokers and agents are registered and supervised by the BCU. The Compilation mentions them in passing and holds the insurer responsible for them, but we found no record.
- The chargeback rules of credit card brands and their time windows are not Uruguayan law, nor are they published by the issuer: any timeframe of that origin is a matter of practice, not law.
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources
- Law 19.678 — Insurance Contract (arts. 6, 13, 24 and 104) — norm
- Law 17.250 — Consumer Relations (arts. 22, 31, 42 and 47) — norm
- Law 19.731 — Credit and debit cards (arts. 13, 14, 15 and 17) — norm
- Law 19.210 — Automatic debit (arts. 68, 70, 72 and 73) — norm
- Law 18.507 — Consumer processes up to 100 UR — norm
- Law 18.212 art. 11 — cap on default interest — norm
- Law 18.331 art. 22 — deadlines of the Risk Center — norm
- BCU — Compilation of Regulation and Control of the Financial System — norm
- BCU — Compilation of Insurance and Reinsurance — norm
- BCU — Complaints and reports from financial users — published by the agency
- Consumer Protection Area — Ministry of Economy and Finance — published by the agency
Contrastado el August 19, 2026. No es asesoramiento legal: es información para que sepas qué pedir y adónde ir.
Would this help someone you know?
Share this page to compare or decide together.