Tienda Inglesa or Itaú Volar Mastercard Black: Which credit card offers more cashback?
Tienda Inglesa wins by a narrow margin: 70 points to Itaú Volar Mastercard Black's 64. Tienda Inglesa leads in points accumulation, redemption, cost, and coverage. Itaú Volar Mastercard Black has the advantage in network reach. Tienda Inglesa is for: regular Tienda Inglesa customers who value a points program with clear value and direct redemption against supermarket purchases. Itaú Volar Mastercard Black is for: high-spending/wealth customers who want the top-of-the-line Volar Mastercard network with premium benefits.
Axle by axle
Rewards programs are compared based on what they actually offer: how many points you accumulate, the value of each point, how easy it is to redeem them, what discounts they provide, and the cost of maintaining the card. A difference of less than 5 points is considered a tie: the score is a research assessment, not a decimal measurement.
| Axis (weight) | English Store | Itaú Volar Mastercard Black | Win |
|---|---|---|---|
| Accumulation (25%) | 82 | 60 | English Store |
| Discount network (25%) | 48 | 78 | Itaú Volar Mastercard Black |
| Exchange (20%) | 78 | 70 | English Store |
| Cost (15%) | 85 | 42 | English Store |
| Flexibility (8%) | 60 | 63 | Draw |
| Coverage (7%) | 66 | 60 | English Store |
| Overall score | 70 | 64 | English Store |
The data, side by side
| Fact | English Store | Itaú Volar Mastercard Black |
|---|---|---|
| Transmitter | Tienda Inglesa (retail); Club Card issued by Scotiabank Uruguay S.A. in Visa (Infinite, Platinum and International), Mastercard International and American Express International | Banco Itaú Uruguay |
| Networks | Visa, Mastercard, Amex | Mastercard |
| Points program | Tienda Inglesa Points Program (Points Card); Club Card doubles points | Fly (Itaú miles) |
| How it accumulates | Terms and conditions in effect since January 1 2026: for transactions greater than $U 90 and less than $U 900, 1 Points are generated; for transactions of $U 900 or more, 15 Points are generated per $U 900, without proration. The old rate of "1 point per $600" and the "little point" of 0,1 point no longer exist. Paying with Club Card debit or credit cards issued by Scotiabank Uruguay S.A. earns double points. The effective return has not changed—15 points of $U 1 on $U 900 are ~1,67% base and ~3,33% with Club Card—: what has changed is the unit of measurement. | Earn 1 Itaú mile for every US$1 (or equivalent in pesos) spent on credit purchases, same rules as Volar. A differentiated rate for the Black segment is not detailed in the public information sheet (assumed to be the same as the airline; not specifically verified). |
| What is the value of a point? | Transparent and fixed value: as of 1/1/2026, each accumulated Point is equivalent to $U 1 (previously the published exchange rate was 1 point = $10). Return: ~1,67% base ($U 15 per $U 900) and ~3,33% with Club Card for double points. | No official ratio published. Not confirmed. |
| How to redeem | Points are deducted from purchases: they can be redeemed in full or in part for any product except cigarettes and services, at Tienda Inglesa and other group locations. The minimum redemption amount has been raised to 150 points (equivalent to the same $U 150 as before, but the published amount has changed). Validity now depends on the document: with a Uruguayan document, it's 6 months, renewable each time a point is earned and accumulated; with a foreign document, it's 24 months without renewal. | Just like Volar: tickets to any airline + catalog, via itauvolar.com.uy/SuperApp. Redemption only for the cardholder. |
| Discounts | Exclusive discounts and promotions for Club/Club Card members. A significant change this year: starting with 01/01/2026, purchases made outside of Tienda Inglesa with Club Card no longer earn points. The double point offer remains valid, but only within Tienda Inglesa and other group stores, considerably reducing the program's reach. The Club Card is issued by Scotiabank and offers additional banking benefits besides double points. | The Itaú benefits network plus the Mastercard Black level, published today in the September fee schedule (2026): from 1/2/2026, the cardholder receives 4 free access to VIP lounges plus 10 access at US$ 10 each per calendar year, and from 15 onwards, pays US$ 38 per access; access for additional cardholders is deducted from the cardholder's allowance. Furthermore, on the Itaú Mastercard line, complimentary travel assistance from Universal Assistance applies exclusively to Black cards, both for the primary cardholder and additional cardholders. |
| Costs | The supermarket's points program is free (registration with ID at the checkout). The American Express Club Card is a Scotiabank product with its own costs (not confirmed here). | UI 1.454/year, ≈ $U 9.664 with the UI of 22/9/2026 ($U 6,6468), confirmed in the official fee schedule, September version 2026 (same value as the 1/8/2026 version; the Visa Infinite costs the same, UI 1.454). The first year is also free for the Black card: the fee schedule states this for all card types, even though the product information sheet does not repeat it. It is charged in 3 installments in local currency, VAT included; additional installments on the Black card pay the same as those on the Gold card. Welcome bonus of 3.500 Itaú miles with the first purchase. Minimum credit limit: to be confirmed. |
| Confirmed data | Yes, according to an official source. | Yes, according to an official source. |
For and against
Tienda Inglesa — Points Program (Points Card / Club Card)
Retail · Tienda Inglesa (retail); Club Card issued by Scotiabank Uruguay S.A. in Visa (Infinite, Platinum and International), Mastercard International and American Express International
In favor
- Value of the TRANSPARENT and fixed point: 1 point = $U 1 (rare in the local market)
- Purchases can be paid for directly with points, in full or in part, for any product except cigarettes and services.
- Club Card doubles the accumulation within Tienda Inglesa (~3,33% return)
- Free membership with ID only; accepts any payment method to accumulate points
Against
- Modest base return (~1,67%) and limited to the Tienda Inglesa/Farma/Deli/Barny's ecosystem
- Valid for 6 months with a Uruguayan document (renewable with each accumulation); 24 months without renewal with a foreign document
- From 01/01/2026, Club Card points will no longer be accumulated for purchases outside of Tienda Inglesa.
- Doubling up on points requires the Club Card, which is a bank card (Scotiabank), not a non-bank issuer card.
- Minimum of 150 points to start redeeming
Itaú Volar Mastercard Black
Bank · Banco Itaú Uruguay
In favor
- Highest level of the Volar range (Mastercard Black)
- 4 free annual entries to VIP lounges (the only Itaú level that retains free access) plus 10 at US$10
- Universal Assistance at no extra cost, exclusive to the Black line, for primary and additional cardholders.
- Same ticket exchange flexibility with any airline
- 3.500-mile welcome bonus
Against
- Highest annual cost in the range (UI 1.454 ≈ $U 9.664)
- Surcharge for purchases abroad: 3% + VAT (1% + VAT with the Full Package; no surcharge with Personal Bank)
- Miles expire after 5 years; no official mile value
- Same accumulation exclusions
Our reading of each one
English Store
The best verifiable effective rate of the set: 15 Points per $U 900 with 1 point = $U 1 (~1,67% base and ~3,33% with Club Card for double points), transparent and fixed value, and free supermarket program. Discounts and coverage are lower compared to the previous review because, starting with 01/01/2026, purchases outside of Tienda Inglesa with Club Card stopped accruing points: the program became locked into a single chain. The 6 month validity (Uruguayan document) and the minimum of 150 Points continue to limit flexibility.
Itaú Volar Mastercard Black
Premium Black-level benefits are now confirmed in the fee schedule (September version 2026, same values as 1/8/2026): it's the only Itaú level that retains free access to VIP lounges (4 per year) and the only Mastercard level with complimentary Universal Assistance. The highest annual cost in the range (UI 1.454 = $U 9.664, not the $9.000 stated in the old conversion) continues to negatively impact the overall cost, and the differentiated rate for the Black tier isn't detailed in the information sheet (assumed to be the same as Volar's), which reduces coverage.
Other comparisons
Would this help someone you know?
Share this page to compare or decide together.