credit cards

Itaú Volar or Scotia Card American Express Points: Which credit card gives more cashback?

Itaú Volar wins by a narrow margin: 67 points to Scotia Points American Express Card's 60. Itaú Volar excels in redemption, cost, and coverage. Itaú Volar is for users who spend in pesos/dollars and want complete flexibility to redeem tickets on any airline, without being tied to a specific mileage program. Scotia Points American Express Card is for frequent travelers who are Scotiabank customers, value VIP lounge access and travel insurance, and use another Visa/MasterCard for everyday domestic expenses. For international travel without surcharges, the Platinum card is currently the only option.

Axle by axle

Rewards programs are compared based on what they actually offer: how many points you accumulate, the value of each point, how easy it is to redeem them, what discounts they provide, and the cost of maintaining the card. A difference of less than 5 points is considered a tie: the score is a research assessment, not a decimal measurement.

Axis (weight)Itaú FlyScotia Card American Express PointsWin
Accumulation (25%)6262Draw
Discount network (25%)6864Draw
Exchange (20%)7258Itaú Fly
Cost (15%)6548Itaú Fly
Flexibility (8%)6568Draw
Coverage (7%)6860Itaú Fly
Overall score6760Itaú Fly

The data, side by side

FactItaú FlyScotia Card American Express Points
TransmitterBanco Itaú UruguayScotiabank Uruguay
NetworksVisa, MastercardAmex
Points programFly (Itaú miles)Scotia Points (Amex International/Centurion lines accumulate points in Membership Rewards, a separate and current program)
How it accumulatesCredit: 1 Itaú mile for every US$1 (or its equivalent in pesos) spent on purchases. Volar Debit: 1 mile for every US$2. Confirmed in the official FAQ and milesItauVolar.html.Beware of the unit: the Amex Gold card earns one point for every dollar (or its equivalent in Uruguayan pesos) spent in Uruguay and abroad, within the Membership Rewards program. The official Scotia Points program table only lists Visa International, Mastercard International, Visa Platinum, and Visa Infinite; it does not include any American Express cards, so attributing 1 point per $U 100 of Scotia Points to the Amex line is not supported by this information. Cash advances do not earn points.
What is the value of a point?No official rate published; the actual value per mile depends on the item redeemed in the Jetmar catalog. Not confirmed.In Scotia Points, 1 point = $U 1. In Membership Rewards, the value of the point in travel or experience redemptions is not published by the issuer: after reviewing the Scotia Points American Express, Amex International, Amex Gold, Amex Metal fact sheets and the rewards programs page, none publish an equivalence or conversion table.
How to redeemMiles redeemable for airline tickets (any airline, no date restrictions), domestic travel packages, technology, fashion, shows, books, and home goods. Tickets provided by Jetmar Viajes. Redemption by the primary cardholder only (additional cardholders cannot redeem). Credit will be issued within 10 business days of the closing date.Two distinct systems coexist and should not be mixed: Amex International/Centurion cards accumulate points in Membership Rewards, American Express's global program, which remains active, separate, and with points that do not expire; Scotia Points American Express cards accumulate points in Scotia Points (1 point = $U 1, redeemable via the app). With the Amex International card, the customer chooses between Membership Rewards and ConnectMiles when signing up.
DiscountsAccess to the Itaú benefits network: year-round discounts at pharmacies, restaurants, supermarkets, fashion retailers, and entertainment venues. Specific percentages/days vary and are not listed on the product page (details unverified).Travel benefits beyond just discounts, but with limits: access to the Carrasco Airport VIP Lounge with a maximum of 3 annual visits per cardholder and per additional cardholder for Gold members (not cumulative; a preferential rate applies for each additional visit), and access via Priority Pass for Platinum members with 10 annual visits for the cardholder and 5 for the additional cardholder. Both cards include 12 annual 72-hour visits to the Carrasco Airport parking lot. Travel accident insurance of up to US$75.000 for Gold members according to the Scotia American Express Points card (the Amex Gold Membership Rewards card states US$300.000: the amount depends on the card type, there is no single figure), 24/7 travel assistance up to US$12.000, additional cards at no charge, and Express Cash at Banred branches and ATMs. Purchases abroad with a 0% surcharge (Platinum) or 1,5% (Gold) + VAT according to the current rate schedule.
Costs1er year at no cost; then UI 864/year, which is ≈ $U 5.743 with the UI of 22/9/2026 ($U 6,6468, INE value). Cost confirmed in the official fee schedule, September version 2026 (cover "September 10, 2026", same UI values as the 1/8/2026 version), for the International line, Visa and Mastercard. It is charged in 3 installments in local currency, VAT included. Minimum declared income ~$26.000. First additional charge discounted at 100%, subsequent charges at 50%. Note: the fee schedule prints "$5.010" next to UI 864, but it is a reference value frozen at the date of printing, not the amount to be charged. The same fee schedule lists the other tiers in the range: Regional UI 471 for Visa and UI 414 for Mastercard (≈ $U 3.131 / $U 2.752), Gold UI 961 (≈ $U 6.388) for both brands, and Visa Infinite UI 1.454 (≈ $U 9.664). The alternative to the individual cost is account packages, which include the card: Light UI 91 per month (includes the International card, international 3% + VAT), Full UI 190 per month (includes the Platinum card, international 1% + VAT), and Personal Bank UI 280 per month (includes the Infinite card, with no surcharge internationally), VAT included.Current official fee schedule (Card F.2540, 20/03/2026): no issuance fee, first year fee free, and additional cards free. Mandatory annual fee including VAT, in Indexed Units: American Express Blue Box International UI 1.000 (≈ $U 6.647), Gold UI 1.250 (≈ $U 8.309), and Platinum UI 1.600 (≈ $U 10.635); American Express Centurion Green UI 1.000, International/Gold UI 1.250, and Platinum UI 2.100 (≈ $U 13.958); Centurion Platinum reprint UI 640 including VAT. The market reference of "~US$ 120/year" does not correspond to any category and was incorrectly named: the fee is in UI, not dollars. Conversion using the UI for 22/9/2026 ($U 6,6468); card reprinted for 22/9/2026 remains unchanged.
Confirmed dataYes, according to an official source.Yes, according to an official source.

For and against

Itaú Fly (Visa/Mastercard International)

Bank · Banco Itaú Uruguay

In favor

  • Miles without a fixed airline: redeem tickets with any airline and without date locks
  • Simple and transparent rate: 1 mile = US$1 credit
  • Welcome bonus of 2.500 miles with your first purchase (3.500 are from Platinum and Mastercard Black; 10.000 are from Personal Bank's Infinite card)
  • Automatic enrollment upon card issuance and the first additional card is 100% free.
  • Extensive catalog (travel, technology, home) plus tickets

Against

  • Surcharge for purchases abroad: 3% + VAT (approximately 3,66% effective rate), and with Visa, an additional 3% on the Visa International exchange rate. Between the two, these fees eat up several times the approximately 1% earned per mile, precisely the spending the card promises to reward. The surcharge is reduced by the account package, not the card itself: with the Full Package it's 1% + VAT, and with Personal Bank there is no surcharge (September 2026 fee schedule).
  • Monetary value per mile not published; depends on the catalog/Jetmar (actual performance uncertain)
  • They do not accumulate cash withdrawals, 0% interest loans, bank interest/charges, or payments through Abitab/Redpagos.
  • Miles expire after 5 years
  • The details of the discount network require login/app, which is not very transparent on the public website.
  • Adding credit to Volar means you will no longer accumulate credit in other bank programs (e.g., LATAM).

Scotia Card American Express Points (Gold / Platinum)

Bank · Scotiabank Uruguay

In favor

  • Traveler-oriented: Carrasco VIP Lounge, robust travel insurance and assistance, plus 12 annual accesses to the Carrasco Airport parking lot.
  • Purchases abroad are subject to a tiered surcharge according to the current fee schedule: 0% on American Express Platinum, 1,5% on American Express Gold, and 3% on International purchases, always plus VAT. The sales slip states "no surcharge," but the 20/03/2026 fee schedule applies.
  • Membership Rewards points do not expire, unlike Scotia Points, which are valid for 36 months.
  • Additional items at no extra cost.

Against

  • American Express network: less accepted than Visa/Mastercard in small businesses in Uruguay.
  • The "no surcharge abroad" policy ceased to be general on October 1, 2025: Amex International became 3% + VAT and Amex Gold became 1,5% + VAT; 0% remained for The Platinum Card and ConnectMiles Platinum.
  • VIP lounges have a limit: 3 annual entries in Gold (after that, preferential price) and 10 in Platinum.
  • Cash advances do not generate points.
  • Membership Rewards point value for travel/experiences not published by the issuer.
  • Annual cost in Indexed Units (indexed to inflation in pesos, not the dollar): Blue Box International UI 1.000 (≈ $U 6.647), Gold UI 1.250 (≈ $U 8.309), Platinum UI 1.600 (≈ $U 10.635); Centurion Platinum reaches UI 2.100 (≈ $U 13.958).

Our reading of each one

Itaú Fly

Confirmed accrual of 1 miles per US$1 (~1-1,5% assuming market value per mile, not published by Itaú) and flexible redemption (tickets on any airline without date restrictions + catalog). Reasonable cost (1 free per year, then UI 864 = $U 5.743 with the UI of 22/9/2026). The accrual/redemption rate is considered conservative because Itaú does not publish an official value-per-mile ratio; redemption is limited to the cardholder.

Scotia Card American Express Points

Strong in travel benefits (Carrasco VIP Lounge, insurance, 24/7 assistance, Carrasco parking) and increased flexibility with the confirmation that Membership Rewards points do not expire, unlike Scotia Points' 36 expiration period. Discounts and costs decrease due to two findings from official sources: the "no surcharge abroad" is no longer the general 1/10/2025 benefit (now 3% for International and 1,5% for Gold, 0% only for Platinum) and the actual annual fee ranges from UI 1.000 to UI 2.100 (US$ 6.647 to US$ 13.958 with the UI of 22/9/2026), well above the previous reference of ~US$120. The value of Membership Rewards points for travel remains unpublished.

Would this help someone you know?

Share this page to compare or decide together.