Creditel or Itaú Volar Mastercard Black: Which credit card offers more cashback?
Itaú Volar Mastercard Black wins by a narrow margin: 64 points to Creditel's 57. Creditel is more cost-effective. Itaú Volar Mastercard Black excels in points accumulation, redemption, flexibility, and coverage. Creditel is for users who prioritize immediate daily discounts and a simple points system, without relying on a bank. Itaú Volar Mastercard Black is for high-spending/net-worth clients who want the top-of-the-line Volar Mastercard with premium benefits.
Axle by axle
Rewards programs are compared based on what they actually offer: how many points you accumulate, the value of each point, how easy it is to redeem them, what discounts they provide, and the cost of maintaining the card. A difference of less than 5 points is considered a tie: the score is a research assessment, not a decimal measurement.
| Axis (weight) | Creditel | Itaú Volar Mastercard Black | Win |
|---|---|---|---|
| Accumulation (25%) | 45 | 60 | Itaú Volar Mastercard Black |
| Discount network (25%) | 75 | 78 | Draw |
| Exchange (20%) | 50 | 70 | Itaú Volar Mastercard Black |
| Cost (15%) | 58 | 42 | Creditel |
| Flexibility (8%) | 52 | 63 | Itaú Volar Mastercard Black |
| Coverage (7%) | 55 | 60 | Itaú Volar Mastercard Black |
| Overall score | 57 | 64 | Itaú Volar Mastercard Black |
The data, side by side
| Fact | Creditel | Itaú Volar Mastercard Black |
|---|---|---|
| Transmitter | Creditel S.A. (Santander Group) | Banco Itaú Uruguay |
| Networks | Mastercard | Mastercard |
| Points program | Credipuntos | Fly (Itaú miles) |
| How it accumulates | Every $25 spent with the Creditel Mastercard earns 1 Credipoint (according to official Creditel communication). Rate confirmed for pesos; equivalent rate for dollar purchases not confirmed here. | Earn 1 Itaú mile for every US$1 (or equivalent in pesos) spent on credit purchases, same rules as Volar. A differentiated rate for the Black segment is not detailed in the public information sheet (assumed to be the same as the airline; not specifically verified). |
| What is the value of a point? | Monetary value per Credipunto (equivalent dollar value of the point redeemed) NOT clearly published; with an accumulation of $25 = 1 point, the actual return depends on the catalog. Not confirmed. | No official ratio published. Not confirmed. |
| How to redeem | Redeem products from the catalog via the app or website, with home delivery. Redeemable SMS options, using the text CANJE to 4242 and the "ShopCreditel" branding, appeared in Creditel communications from 2021-2023 but are no longer listed on the official website: consider these as historical channels, not currently confirmed. | Just like Volar: tickets to any airline + catalog, via itauvolar.com.uy/SuperApp. Redemption only for the cardholder. |
| Discounts | Strong focus on discounts: up to 20% off every day in various categories and interest-free installment plans/promotions. First year of international card free depending on the promotion. | The Itaú benefits network plus the Mastercard Black level, published today in the September fee schedule (2026): from 1/2/2026, the cardholder receives 4 free access to VIP lounges plus 10 access at US$ 10 each per calendar year, and from 15 onwards, pays US$ 38 per access; access for additional cardholders is deducted from the cardholder's allowance. Furthermore, on the Itaú Mastercard line, complimentary travel assistance from Universal Assistance applies exclusively to Black cards, both for the primary cardholder and additional cardholders. |
| Costs | Issuance/maintenance costs not confirmed in the sources consulted; frequent bonus promotions in the first year. | UI 1.454/year, ≈ $U 9.664 with the UI of 22/9/2026 ($U 6,6468), confirmed in the official fee schedule, September version 2026 (same value as the 1/8/2026 version; the Visa Infinite costs the same, UI 1.454). The first year is also free for the Black card: the fee schedule states this for all card types, even though the product information sheet does not repeat it. It is charged in 3 installments in local currency, VAT included; additional installments on the Black card pay the same as those on the Gold card. Welcome bonus of 3.500 Itaú miles with the first purchase. Minimum credit limit: to be confirmed. |
| Confirmed data | Partial | Yes, according to an official source. |
For and against
Creditel — Credipuntos
Non-bank issuer · Creditel S.A. (Santander Group)
In favor
- Clear and simple accumulation rule ($25 = 1 Credipoint)
- Online redemption via the app or website, with home delivery
- Competitive daily discounts of up to 20%
- Santander Group Support
Against
- The actual value of the point in the redemption is not transparent: the page itself has an accordion titled "What is its value?" whose answer is never provided.
- It is the only issuer in its segment that does not publish a downloadable rate book or tariff schedule, even though BCU regulations require one.
- The program is more focused on discounts than on accumulation as a value generator.
Itaú Volar Mastercard Black
Bank · Banco Itaú Uruguay
In favor
- Highest level of the Volar range (Mastercard Black)
- 4 free annual entries to VIP lounges (the only Itaú level that retains free access) plus 10 at US$10
- Universal Assistance at no extra cost, exclusive to the Black line, for primary and additional cardholders.
- Same ticket exchange flexibility with any airline
- 3.500-mile welcome bonus
Against
- Highest annual cost in the range (UI 1.454 ≈ $U 9.664)
- Surcharge for purchases abroad: 3% + VAT (1% + VAT with the Full Package; no surcharge with Personal Bank)
- Miles expire after 5 years; no official mile value
- Same accumulation exclusions
Our reading of each one
Creditel
Good focus on discounts (up to 20% every day, interest-free installments) and communicated accumulation rate ($25 = 1 Credipoint). It's rated conservatively because the Credipoint's monetary equivalent isn't published (the actual return depends on the ShopCreditel catalog), the dollar accumulation rate isn't confirmed, and the maintenance fee isn't listed in the sources.
Itaú Volar Mastercard Black
Premium Black-level benefits are now confirmed in the fee schedule (September version 2026, same values as 1/8/2026): it's the only Itaú level that retains free access to VIP lounges (4 per year) and the only Mastercard level with complimentary Universal Assistance. The highest annual cost in the range (UI 1.454 = $U 9.664, not the $9.000 stated in the old conversion) continues to negatively impact the overall cost, and the differentiated rate for the Black tier isn't detailed in the information sheet (assumed to be the same as Volar's), which reduces coverage.
Other comparisons
Would this help someone you know?
Share this page to compare or decide together.