Itaú Volar Mastercard Black or Scotia Points: Which credit card gives more cashback?
The Itaú Volar Mastercard Black and Scotia Points are virtually tied (64 vs. 62 points): the decision isn't based on the average score, but rather on which one excels in what matters most to you. The Itaú Volar Mastercard Black has the advantage in network coverage. Scotia Points has the advantage in cost and coverage. The Itaú Volar Mastercard Black is for: high-spending/high-net-worth clients who want the top-of-the-line Volar Mastercard with premium benefits. Scotia Points is for: Platinum or Infinite Scotiabank clients who use the card frequently: redemption via the app is one of the most flexible on the market, but it penalizes those who leave the card unused.
Axle by axle
Rewards programs are compared based on what they actually offer: how many points you accumulate, the value of each point, how easy it is to redeem them, what discounts they provide, and the cost of maintaining the card. A difference of less than 5 points is considered a tie: the score is a research assessment, not a decimal measurement.
| Axis (weight) | Itaú Volar Mastercard Black | Scotia Points | Win |
|---|---|---|---|
| Accumulation (25%) | 60 | 58 | Draw |
| Discount network (25%) | 78 | 58 | Itaú Volar Mastercard Black |
| Exchange (20%) | 70 | 72 | Draw |
| Cost (15%) | 42 | 55 | Scotia Points |
| Flexibility (8%) | 63 | 60 | Draw |
| Coverage (7%) | 60 | 80 | Scotia Points |
| Overall score | 64 | 62 | Draw |
The data, side by side
| Fact | Itaú Volar Mastercard Black | Scotia Points |
|---|---|---|
| Transmitter | Banco Itaú Uruguay | Scotiabank Uruguay |
| Networks | Mastercard | Visa, Mastercard, Amex |
| Points program | Fly (Itaú miles) | Scotia Points |
| How it accumulates | Earn 1 Itaú mile for every US$1 (or equivalent in pesos) spent on credit purchases, same rules as Volar. A differentiated rate for the Black segment is not detailed in the public information sheet (assumed to be the same as the airline; not specifically verified). | The rate is tiered by card category, not a general 1 points per $100: Visa International and Mastercard International earn 1 points per $150 (~0,67% return), Visa Platinum 1 points per $100 (~1%), and Visa Infinite 1 points per $80 (~1,25%). Entry-level cards, which are the most widely used, yield about a third less than the "1%" associated with the program. New features in the July 2026 terms and conditions (New Scotia Points, for cards requested from 14/7/2025 onwards and migrated cards): a first purchase bonus of 500 points on Visa Platinum and Visa Infinite cards (International cards do not have this bonus) and a minimum spending bonus of 700 points in the first 4 months on International cards ($U 50.000), 1.500 on Platinum ($U 90.000), and 2.500 on Infinite ($U 120.000). Points are credited up to 10 business days after the closing date. |
| What is the value of a point? | No official ratio published. Not confirmed. | 1 Scotia Point = $U 1 upon redemption. Actual return depends on the tier: ~0,67% for International, ~1% for Platinum, and ~1,25% for Infinite. Value confirmed on the official website. |
| How to redeem | Just like Volar: tickets to any airline + catalog, via itauvolar.com.uy/SuperApp. Redemption only for the cardholder. | 100% self-managed redemption through the Scotia Mobile App: you can redeem points for any purchase payable with the card ('if you can pay with the card, you can redeem with points'), at a rate of 1 point = $U 1. But there's a catch: the purchase must exceed $U 700, be less than 90 days old, and you must have enough points to cover the TOTAL amount (partial redemptions are not allowed). Redemption is only available through the App: there are no redemptions via the website or in branches. Points expire 36 months after being earned, and the terms and conditions of July 2026 add the expiration of the TOTAL balance after 180 calendar days without a purchase made with the card. |
| Discounts | The Itaú benefits network plus the Mastercard Black level, published today in the September fee schedule (2026): from 1/2/2026, the cardholder receives 4 free access to VIP lounges plus 10 access at US$ 10 each per calendar year, and from 15 onwards, pays US$ 38 per access; access for additional cardholders is deducted from the cardholder's allowance. Furthermore, on the Itaú Mastercard line, complimentary travel assistance from Universal Assistance applies exclusively to Black cards, both for the primary cardholder and additional cardholders. | The program's focus is on point accumulation; discounts at participating businesses are offered through specific campaigns (not a fixed schedule like BROU). Partner programs active as of September 2026: Scotia Points, Membership Rewards (American Express), Copa ConnectMiles, and Club Card (Tienda Inglesa, double points). Two programs previously listed in the ranking are no longer valid: Gaviotas was discontinued on February 1 of 2026 (balance redeemable until 31/12/2026 at Montevideo Shopping), and Sonrisas was replaced by Scotia Points. MileagePlus (United) and Smiles are listed on the site only as reference links, without any expiration date or discontinuation notice: their status is pending confirmation. |
| Costs | UI 1.454/year, ≈ $U 9.664 with the UI of 22/9/2026 ($U 6,6468), confirmed in the official fee schedule, September version 2026 (same value as the 1/8/2026 version; the Visa Infinite costs the same, UI 1.454). The first year is also free for the Black card: the fee schedule states this for all card types, even though the product information sheet does not repeat it. It is charged in 3 installments in local currency, VAT included; additional installments on the Black card pay the same as those on the Gold card. Welcome bonus of 3.500 Itaú miles with the first purchase. Minimum credit limit: to be confirmed. | Official fee schedule (Personal Credit Card Booklet F.2540, 20/03/2026): Issuance and first year free. Mandatory annual fee including VAT and denominated in Indexed Units (i.e., indexed to inflation in pesos, not the dollar): Visa and Mastercard International UI 1.000 (≈ $U 6.647), Platinum UI 1.250 (≈ $U 8.309), and Infinite UI 1.600 (≈ $U 10.635). Additional cards free; reprint UI 180. Purchases abroad, mandatory fee + VAT per purchase: 3% on International and Mastercard Gold, 1,5% on American Express Gold and Visa Platinum, 0% on American Express Platinum and Visa Infinite. And a charge not listed in the commercial document: the "additional exchange rate" for each transaction in a currency other than the dollar, 6% for Visa International, 4,5% for Visa Platinum, 3% for Visa Infinite, and 3% for Mastercard. Late payment collection management fee of UI 10 + VAT, up to 5 times per year. Conversion to pesos using the UI of 22/9/2026 ($U 6,6468). The market reference of "~$U 6.000/year" for Platinum falls short: the actual value is ~38% higher. |
| Confirmed data | Yes, according to an official source. | Yes, according to an official source. |
For and against
Itaú Volar Mastercard Black
Bank · Banco Itaú Uruguay
In favor
- Highest level of the Volar range (Mastercard Black)
- 4 free annual entries to VIP lounges (the only Itaú level that retains free access) plus 10 at US$10
- Universal Assistance at no extra cost, exclusive to the Black line, for primary and additional cardholders.
- Same ticket exchange flexibility with any airline
- 3.500-mile welcome bonus
Against
- Highest annual cost in the range (UI 1.454 ≈ $U 9.664)
- Surcharge for purchases abroad: 3% + VAT (1% + VAT with the Full Package; no surcharge with Personal Bank)
- Miles expire after 5 years; no official mile value
- Same accumulation exclusions
Scotia Points
Bank · Scotiabank Uruguay
In favor
- Simple and transparent point value: 1 point = $U 1 (no catalogs with hidden redemption rates).
- Redeem for any purchase payable with the card, not a closed catalog: it remains one of the most liquid among banking programs.
- Unified program: Visa and Mastercard points accumulate in the same Scotia Points account.
- Issuance, first year and additional years free of charge, with public and dated price list (booklet F.2540 of 20/03/2026).
- Bonuses from the July 2026 base: 500 points for the first purchase in Platinum and Infinite and 700/1.500/2.500 points for spending $U 50.000/90.000/120.000 in the first 4 months.
Against
- Points expire after 36 months, and the accumulated TOTAL also expires if you go 180 consecutive days without making a purchase with the card.
- International cards accumulate 1 point for every $U 150 (~0,67%), not the ~1% attributed to the program.
- To redeem, the purchase must exceed $U 700, be less than 90 days old, and be 100% covered with points: there is no partial redemption.
- The exchange is only through the Scotia Mobile App: there is no website or branch.
- Discounts with stores that are less structured than BROU's fixed scheme of days and limits.
Our reading of each one
Itaú Volar Mastercard Black
Premium Black-level benefits are now confirmed in the fee schedule (September version 2026, same values as 1/8/2026): it's the only Itaú level that retains free access to VIP lounges (4 per year) and the only Mastercard level with complimentary Universal Assistance. The highest annual cost in the range (UI 1.454 = $U 9.664, not the $9.000 stated in the old conversion) continues to negatively impact the overall cost, and the differentiated rate for the Black tier isn't detailed in the information sheet (assumed to be the same as Volar's), which reduces coverage.
Scotia Points
A major correction has been made compared to the previous review. The accumulation rate drops from 74 to 58 because the rate is not 1 point per $U100 across the board: International cards, which make up the bulk of the portfolio, accumulate 1 point per $U150 (approximately 0,67%). The redemption rate drops from 95 to 72 because the slogan "if you can pay with the card, you can redeem it" has four conditions that the ranking did not consider (minimum $U700, less than 90 days, covering 100% of the amount, and only through the app) and an inactivity clause that erases the entire balance after 6 months without a purchase. The cost increases slightly with the release of the official fee schedule, which also confirms that the charge is in Indexed Units (UI) and not in dollars.
Other comparisons
Would this help someone you know?
Share this page to compare or decide together.