BROU Debit or Itaú Visa Debit: which one is cheaper to use to pay in dollars
Itaú Visa Debit wins by a narrow margin: 76 points to BROU Debit's 64. BROU Debit has the advantage in spread and cost. Itaú Visa Debit has the advantage in commission and USD balance. BROU Debit is for: BROU customers who already have a dollar savings account and prefer to use their bank. Itaú Visa Debit is for: Itaú customers who maintain a dollar account and pay for their purchases in USD from there.
Axle by axle
What's being compared here is the real cost of spending in dollars: the purchase commission, whether VAT is added, the fixed transaction fee, and whether you can fund the card directly in dollars to avoid the conversion. A difference of less than 5 points is considered a tie: the score is based on research, not a decimal measurement.
| Axis (weight) | BROU Debit | Itaú Visa Debit | Win |
|---|---|---|---|
| Commission abroad (26%) | 52 | 100 | Itaú Visa Debit |
| Exchange rate spread (22%) | 70 | 65 | BROU Debit |
| Balance in dollars (16%) | 85 | 90 | Itaú Visa Debit |
| Balance return (10%) | 20 | 22 | Draw |
| Card cost (10%) | 70 | 62 | BROU Debit |
| Acceptance (9%) | 75 | 78 | Draw |
| Top-up (7%) | 85 | 85 | Draw |
| Overall score | 64 | 76 | Itaú Visa Debit |
The data, side by side
| Fact | BROU Debit | Itaú Visa Debit |
|---|---|---|
| Guy | Bank debit | Bank debit |
| Commission for purchases abroad | 3% (excluding VAT) | 0% (excluding VAT) |
| Fixed charge per transaction | None declared | None declared |
| Can you fund it in dollars? | Yes, you avoid the conversion | Yes, you avoid the conversion |
| How to convert | From a peso account, it converts "at the exchange rate shown on the transaction" (selling side), plus the foreign transaction fee. By linking a dollar savings account, purchases in USD are debited directly in dollars. | With a debit linked to a peso account, Visa converts the transaction using Visa International's wholesale rate, and Itaú adds approximately 3% on top of that rate. With a debit linked to a dollar account and a purchase in USD, there is no conversion and no 3% fee. |
| Actual cost | International purchases: 3% with standard Mastercard Debit (2% with Visa Institutional and Rewards cards). The fee schedule does not specify VAT on this debit commission. No fixed charge for online purchases. | Debit cards have no surcharge for international purchases (0%). The fee only applies if you pay in pesos: approximately 3% markup on the Visa rate. Itaú credit cards do charge 3% + VAT. |
| Confirmed data | Yes, according to an official source. | Yes, according to an official source. |
For and against
BROU Debit
Bank debit · Banco República (BROU)
In favor
- You can link a dollar savings account
- Some plastics charge 2% instead of 3%.
- The card that almost everyone already has
Against
- 3% commission on the standard Mastercard Debit
- From pesos, spread (sell side)
- Some game stores reject debit cards.
Itaú Visa Debit
Bank debit · Itaú Uruguay
In favor
- Debit card with no surcharge for purchases abroad
- Paying from a dollar account, cost ~0
- Cheaper than the Itaú credit card for purchases in USD
Against
- From balances in pesos, ~3% markup on the Visa rate
- Some game stores reject debit cards.
- Tied to having an account/package at the bank
Our reading of each one
BROU Debit
It works and allows you to pay from a dollar savings account, but the 3% commission (2% on some cards) puts it above OCA Blue or the Itaú/BBVA debit card for buying in USD.
Itaú Visa Debit
Very convenient if you have a dollar account: 0% surcharge and no conversion. If you pay in pesos, the approximately 3% surcharge on top of the Visa rate makes it similar to prepaid cards with a commission.
Sources
Would this help someone you know?
Share this page to compare or decide together.