debit and prepaid cards

BROU Debit or Scotiabank Visa Debit: which one is cheaper to use to pay in dollars

BROU Debit and Scotiabank Visa Debit are virtually tied (64 points to 64): the decision isn't based on the average, but rather on which one excels in what matters most to you. BROU Debit comes out on top in terms of performance and cost. BROU Debit is for: BROU customers who already have a dollar savings account and prefer to use their bank. Scotiabank Visa Debit is for: Scotiabank customers with a dollar account who purchase services and subscriptions from abroad.

Axle by axle

What's being compared here is the real cost of spending in dollars: the purchase commission, whether VAT is added, the fixed transaction fee, and whether you can fund the card directly in dollars to avoid the conversion. A difference of less than 5 points is considered a tie: the score is based on research, not a decimal measurement.

Axis (weight)BROU DebitScotiabank Visa DebitWin
Commission abroad (26%)5252Draw
Exchange rate spread (22%)7072Draw
Balance in dollars (16%)8588Draw
Balance return (10%)2015BROU Debit
Card cost (10%)7062BROU Debit
Acceptance (9%)7578Draw
Top-up (7%)8585Draw
Overall score6464Draw

The data, side by side

FactBROU DebitScotiabank Visa Debit
GuyBank debitBank debit
Commission for purchases abroad3% (excluding VAT)3% + IVA 22%
Fixed charge per transactionNone declaredNone declared
Can you fund it in dollars?Yes, you avoid the conversionYes, you avoid the conversion
How to convertFrom a peso account, it converts "at the exchange rate shown on the transaction" (selling side), plus the foreign transaction fee. By linking a dollar savings account, purchases in USD are debited directly in dollars.With direct debit from a peso account, the exchange rate is the bank's selling rate (spread not published). By linking a dollar deposit account, the Visa Debit card debits directly from the USD balance and avoids the conversion.
Actual costInternational purchases: 3% with standard Mastercard Debit (2% with Visa Institutional and Rewards cards). The fee schedule does not specify VAT on this debit commission. No fixed charge for online purchases.Purchases abroad: 3% surcharge (Official Visa Debit FAQ). The VAT on this fee follows the usual standard in Uruguay, although the debit card page doesn't spell it out.
Confirmed dataYes, according to an official source.Yes, according to an official source.

For and against

BROU Debit

Bank debit · Banco República (BROU)

In favor

  • You can link a dollar savings account
  • Some plastics charge 2% instead of 3%.
  • The card that almost everyone already has

Against

  • 3% commission on the standard Mastercard Debit
  • From pesos, spread (sell side)
  • Some game stores reject debit cards.

Scotiabank Visa Debit

Bank debit · Scotiabank Uruguay

In favor

  • You can debit from a dollar account
  • International visa suitable for services and shops abroad
  • High limit on dollar purchases

Against

  • 3% surcharge for purchases abroad
  • The VAT on the commission is not spelled out for debit
  • From pesos, seller's spread

Our reading of each one

BROU Debit

It works and allows you to pay from a dollar savings account, but the 3% commission (2% on some cards) puts it above OCA Blue or the Itaú/BBVA debit card for buying in USD.

Scotiabank Visa Debit

The 3% surcharge puts it on par with BROU and standard Santander. Its advantage is that it debits from a dollar account, which eliminates the spread but not the 3%.

Would this help someone you know?

Share this page to compare or decide together.