BTG Pactual or Scotiabank: which one is better for your everyday money
BTG Pactual wins by a narrow margin: 60 points to Scotiabank's 49. BTG Pactual excels in app performance, customer service, and dollar-based transactions. Scotiabank leads in product offerings and coverage. BTG Pactual is for: affluent individuals seeking private banking, global investments, and a dedicated account manager. It's not suitable for everyday use. Scotiabank is for: those who already have a Scotia Points/Club Card Tienda Inglesa package and use it.
Axle by axle
Each bank and digital wallet is scored on six axes, with equal weight for all: app, fees, customer service, dollar transactions, products, and coverage. The overall score is the weighted sum, never a handwritten number. A difference of less than 5 points is considered a tie: the score is a research assessment, not a decimal measurement.
| Axis (weight) | BTG Pactual | Scotiabank | Win |
|---|---|---|---|
| App and digital experience (22%) | 78 | 30 | BTG Pactual |
| Commissions and costs (20%) | 42 | 42 | Draw |
| Customer service and reputation (18%) | 56 | 36 | BTG Pactual |
| Dollars and transfers (15%) | 82 | 70 | BTG Pactual |
| Products and benefits (13%) | 62 | 74 | Scotiabank |
| Coverage and acceptance (12%) | 30 | 60 | Scotiabank |
| Overall score | 60 | 49 | BTG Pactual |
The data, side by side
| Fact | BTG Pactual | Scotiabank |
|---|---|---|
| Guy | Brazilian private bank (formerly HSBC Uruguay) | Private (Canadian) bank |
| Tier | C | D |
| In one line | The former HSBC with a new brand: same bank, same premium focus. | The one that receives the most service complaints. |
| It started | July 10, 2026 | — |
| iBanking App | 4,8/5 (still the same as HSBC) | — |
| Account for individuals | Excellence (premium) only | — |
| Branches | ~6, main office by appointment | — |
| Attention | New brand since 10/07/2026 (ex-HSBC): data and customer experience are still being developed | recurring complaints |
| Scotia Mobile App | — | 2,45/5 Play · 2,35/5 iOS |
| Free ATMs | — | cut 05/2026 |
For and against
BTG Pactual
Brazilian private bank (formerly HSBC Uruguay)
In favor
- The transfer went smoothly: same app (iBanca, 4,8/5), same phone number (2915 1010), same branches, same team, and same local CEO. HSBC itself stated that "it will not affect the continuity of products, services, or customer service channels."
- Excellence is the former HSBC Premier by another name: assigned account executive, VISA Infinite with VIP lounges, multi-currency accounts (UYU/USD/EUR/GBP/UI), global funds, bonds, ADRs and ETFs.
- Behind it is a large group: BTG Pactual manages US$497 billion and Euromoney chose it as the Best Private Bank in Latin America in 2025.
Against
- It's a brand of days: it launched on July 10, 2026, and there isn't a single review or independent customer experience yet. We gave it a conservative rating and will be reviewing it.
- 100% premium showcase: the ONLY personal account they advertise is Excellence — their own website titles it "Premium Banking". HSBC's mass-market accounts (Personal Account, Income Account) are not listed on their website.
- Minimal footprint: ~6 branches and a main office (WTC) that operates by appointment only: "coordinate with your account executive". No Apple Pay or Google Pay.
- The app is still published as "HSBC Uruguay - iBanca" under the HSBC developer account: it is missing the republication under BTG and there is no date.
Scotiabank
Private (Canadian) bank
In favor
- Good reward programs (Scotia Points, Club Card Tienda Inglesa) and backing from a large Canadian bank.
- Branches in all departmental capitals and a wide network in Montevideo.
Against
- The worst app on the board, and by a considerable margin: Scotia Mobile scores 2,45/5 on Google Play (3.700 reviews) and 2,35/5 on the App Store. 82% of the 60 most recent reviews are one-star: logins that freeze at night, transfers that fail.
- Poor telephone support, delays in opening an account, and billing errors.
- Benefits erosion: since May 2026, Banred has cut free withdrawals from the Basic Salary Account to 6 per month.
Our reading of each one
BTG Pactual
On July 10, 2026, HSBC Uruguay became BTG Pactual: the acquisition (US$175 million, approved by the BCU in June) was finalized, hsbc.com.uy was reduced to a website, and online banking moved to ibanca.btgpactual.uy. For customers, for now, everything remains the same: same app, same phone number, same branches, same team. What changes is the direction—the only personal account it offers is "Excellence," which its own website calls "Premium Banking": the former HSBC Premier account with a new name. It claims to want to be in the top 3 in the country within two or three years, but today its offering is MORE premium than HSBC's, not less. It's still in its early stages: we rated it conservative and reviewed it in weeks.
Scotiabank
We made a big mistake here: we said "the app does the job," but it's actually the worst banking app in the country—2,45/5 on Play, 2,35/5 on the App Store, and 82% of the latest reviews are one star. Add to that the poor phone support and the reduction in free Banred withdrawals, and it's clear why it has the most complaints. The rewards programs are the only thing keeping it afloat. We lowered the app's rating from 66 to 30, and it dropped to a D.
Would this help someone you know?
Share this page to compare or decide together.